Here is a catalog of comparison between "The Empire Strikes Back" special edition DVD and accompanying soundtrack. The film timings (hour:minutes:seconds) are listed on the left, with approximate corresponding timings on the soundtrack (disc #, track #, minutes:seconds) on the right.
0:00:00-0:00:02 = no music 0:00:02-0:00:22 = D1, T1, 0:00-0:21 Curiously, in the film the last chord of the opening fanfare is held about a second longer than on the soundtrack. Presumably they used different takes for the film and soundtrack. Why? I have no idea. 0:00:22-0:00:29 = no music 0:00:29-0:01:59 = D1, T2, 0:00-1:31 0:01:59-0:02:54 = D1, T4, 0:00-0:54 0:02:54-0:04:17 = D1, T2, 2:30-3:53 0:04:17-0:04:26 = D1, T7, 3:20-3:29 0:04:26-0:05:46 = no music 0:05:46-0:07:04 = D1, T2, 5:22-6:41 0:07:04-0:08:21 = no music 0:08:21-0:10:09 = D1, T3, 0:00-1:42 Here the music matches, but not the timing (what takes 108 seconds in the film lasts 106 seconds in the soundtrack). I assume this is the result of different takes being used. 0:10:09-0:12:56 = no music 0:12:56-0:15:14 = D1, T3, 4:29-6:48 0:15:14-0:15:29 = no music 0:15:29-0:15:31 = D2, T11, 5:23-5:26 0:15:31-0:15:34 = D2, T11, 5:23-5:26 0:15:34-0:15:37 = D2, T11, 5:23-5:26 0:15:37-0:15:38 = D2, T11, 5:23-5:24 Notice that this music was actually written for the end of the film. As a result, it took some editing to get it to fit properly. Consequently, the couple of seconds starting at D2, T11, 5:23 are heard four times in a row. 0:15:38-0:16:02 = D2, T11, 5:34-5:58 0:16:02-0:16:12 = D2, T11, 6:11-6:21 0:16:12-0:16:30 = D1, T3, 7:54-8:11 0:16:30-0:16:49 = D1, T3, 0:10-0:29 0:16:49-0:19:47 = no music 0:19:47-0:21:30 = D1, T4, 3:18-4:16 0:21:30-0:21:55 = no music 0:21:55-0:25:52 = D1, T5, 0:01-4:01 0:25:52-0:26:15 = no music 0:26:15-0:29:31 = D1, T5, 4:27-7:36 0:29:31-0:33:15 = D1, T5, 7:40-11:28 0:33:15-0:33:40 = D1, T5, 11:16-11:41 (Notice the repeat of 11:16-11:28) 0:33:40-0:35:37 = D1, T5, 11:43-13:40 0:35:37-0:35:45 = no music 0:35:45-0:36:31 = D1, T5, 13:51-14:37 0:36:31-0:36:49 = no music 0:36:49-0:37:16 = D1, T6 0:01-0:27 0:37:16-0:39:40 = D1, T6, 0:29-2:54 0:39:40-0:40:48 = D1, T6, 2:57-4:05 0:40:48-0:41:35 = no music 0:41:35-0:42:55 = D1, T7, 0:00-1:20 0:42:55-0:42:56 = D1, T7, 1:19-1:20 0:42:56-0:43:26 = D1, T7, 1:19-1:48 Notice how 1:19-1:20 is actually heard three times in a row. 0:43:26-0:43:28 = no music 0:43:28-0:45:09 = D1, T7, 1:48-3:30 0:45:09-0:46:09 = no music 0:46:09-0:47:28 = D1, T7, 3:33-4:51 0:47:28-0:49:45 = no music 0:49:45-0:50:08 = D1, T8, 1:48-2:10 0:50:08-0:50:17 = D1, T8, 2:04-2:11 0:50:17-0:50:22 = D1, T8, 2:24-2:29 These last two don't line up perfectly. I assume a different take was used in the film than was used in the soundtrack. 0:50:22-0:50:46 = no music 0:50:46-0:52:19 = D1, T9, 0:01-1:34 0:52:19-0:53:47 = D1, T9, 1:35-3:03 0:53:47-0:54:31 = D1, T9, 2:39-3:25 Notice that 2:39-3:03 is heard twice in a row. 0:54:31-0:55:36 = no music 0:55:36-0:57:42 = D1, T10, 0:02-2:08 0:57:42-0:58:44 = no music 0:58:44-1:01:04 = D1, T10, 3:16-5:36 1:01:04-1:02:32 = no music 1:02:32-1:05:21 = D1, T11, 1:36-4:26 1:05:21-1:05:56 = D1, T11, 4:30-5:06 1:05:56-1:06:09 = no music 1:06:09-1:09:07 = D2, T3, 0:06-3:04 1:09:07-1:09:46 = no music 1:09:46-1:12:50 = D2, T4, 0:00-3:04 1:12:50-1:13:37 = D2, T4, 3:05-3:52 1:13:37-1:14:13 = no music 1:14:13-1:14:39 = D2, T5, 0:26-0:52 1:14:39-1:15:54 = no music 1:15:54-1:16:30 = D2, T5, 1:16-1:51 1:16:30-1:16:37 = D2, T5, 1:47-1:54 1:16:37-1:18:28 = D2, T5, 1:56-3:47 1:18:28-1:19:52 = D2, T5, 3:51-5:17 1:19:52-1:21:35 = no music 1:21:35-1:25:27 = D2, T6, 0:00-3:53 1:25:27-1:25:30 = no music 1:25:30-1:25:42 = D2, T7, 0:01-0:12 1:25:42-1:25:57 = D2, T7, 2:18-2:33 1:25:57-1:26:37 = D2, T7, 0:20-1:00 1:26:37-1:27:46 = no music 1:27:46-1:29:21 = D2, T7, 1:00-2:36 1:29:21-1:29:48 = no music 1:29:48-1:30:50 = D2, T7, 2:44-3:45 1:30:50-1:31:23 = no music 1:31:23-1:33:51 = D2, T8, 0:00-2:29 1:33:51-1:34:21 = no music 1:34:21-1:34:37 = D2, T9, 0:01-0:17 1:34:37-1:36:31 = D2, T9, 0:20-2:14 1:36:31-1:36:33 = D2, T9, 2:16-2:18 1:36:33-1:36:50 = D2, T9, 2:18-2:34 Several minute edits around here, making the timing unusual and inexact. 1:36:50-1:37:04 = no music 1:37:04-1:37:51 = D2, T9, 3:30-4:17 1:37:51-1:37:54 = unknown music There is an extra brass chord the film that doesn't seem to exist in the soundtrack. 1:37:54-1:39:12 = D2, T9, 4:17-5:35 1:39:12-1:40:27 = D2, T9, 5:37-6:51 1:40:27-1:41:46 = no music 1:41:46-1:43:54 = D2, T9, 8:12-10:20 1:43:54-1:45:52 = no music 1:45:52-1:47:06 = D2, T10, 0:26-1:42 1:47:06-1:49:44 = D2, T10, 1:38-4:15 1:49:44-1:50:27 = no music 1:50:27-1:52:22 = D2, T11, 0:00-1:56 1:52:22-1:54:17 = D2, T11, 1:55-3:51 1:54:17-1:54:26 = unknown music 1:54:26-1:54:40 = D2, T11, 3:57-4:11 1:54:40-1:55:18 = D2, T11, 4:08-4:46 1:55:18-1:55:30 = D2, T11, 4:51-5:02 1:55:30-1:55:55 = D2, T11, 5:04-5:29 1:55:55-1:55:59 = D2, T11, 0:02-0:06 1:55:59-1:56:15 = unknown music 1:56:15-1:56:21 = D2, T11, 5:27-5:32 1:56:21-1:56:49 = D2, T11, 5:36-5:54 1:56:49-1:56:56 = no music 1:56:56-1:58:56 = D2, T11, 6:14-8:14 1:58:56-1:58:59 = D2, T11, 5:24-5:27 1:58:59-1:59:48 = D2, T11, 8:14-9:03 1:59:48-2:00:09 = D2, T4, 0:31-0:52 2:00:08-2:00:40 = D2, T12, 0:01-0:34 2:00:40-2:01:34 = D2 T12, 0:29-1:22 2:01:34-2:04:36 = D2, T12, 1:34-4:37 There is a noticeable edit at 2:03:41 (right where the Imperial March begins a sustained high C is present in the soundtrack, but missing in the film), suggesting a different take was used than the one on the soundtrack. 2:04:36-2:07:20 = D2, T12, 3:42-6:25
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
The Music of Star WarsThese posts will help focus and develop my analyses of John Williams' film scores. Archives
December 2019
Categories
All
|