FLIP SIDE BEATLES: presentations, books, musical analysis
  • Beatles Minute
  • Pop Goes the Theory
  • Calendar
    • Upcoming Events
    • Past Events
    • Newsletter Sign-Up
  • Blogs
    • Beatles Blog
    • Pop Music Blog
    • Star Wars Blog
    • Origami Blog
    • Shakespeare Blog
  • Contact

Music in The Comedy of Errors

6/14/2020

0 Comments

 
In his book Shakespeare: His Music and Song, A.H. Moncur-Sime writes of the Comedy of Errors, "This seems to be one of the very few plays in which music bears not the slightest part." (p. 99) And John H. Long, in his book Shakespeare's Use of Music, hypothesizes that the lack of music might have been "because there was no dramatic purpose to be served by music. He could have inserted an extraneous song or two, as was often done in the plays of the period, but he did not choose to do so." (p. 52) But while there are no specific songs in the script, there are four explicit musical references - and they do serve dramatic purposes.

The first comes 2.2. Unbeknownst to him, Antipholus of Syrause (hereon abbreviated AofS) has been mistaken for his identical twin brother, Antipholus of Ephesus (AofE) by Adriana, AofE's wife. “The time was once, when thou unurg'd wouldst vow / That never words were music to thine ear … Unless I spake,” she admonishes who she thinks is her husband. “[H]ow comes it, / That thou art then estranged from thyself?” (113-14 & 119-20) The musical reference in this case emphasizes AofE's affection for his wife, and thus contributes to her sense of betrayal that her “husband” no longer seems to recognize her.

The second occurrence is in 3.2. Not understanding the situation, AofS plays along (pretends to be Adriana's husband) until he spies Adriana's sister, Luciana, whereupon he falls in love with her. Once AofS and Luciana are alone together for the first time, he admits his romantic interest. “Your weeping sister is no wife of mine,” he says honestly, though Luciana doesn't believe him. “Nor to her bed no homage do I owe: / Far more, far more, to you do I decline.” (42-4) How curious that he says “decline” when “incline” is the more obvious word choice – he is inclined (motivated) to love Luciana over Adriana, not declined (politely refusing). But of course this is no error on Shakespeare's part: Decline in this instance might also mean “lay down” (ie: in a bed together). And if we instead define decline as “go down”, there might even be a whiff of cunnilingus in this linguistic choice. Anyway, Luciana, still thinking that AofS is AofE and thus her brother-in-law, is horrified by the suggestion that she would so betray her sister. But AofS persists. “[T]rain me not, sweet mermaid with thy note, / To drown me in thy sister's flood of tears”, he urges. “Sing, siren, for thyself, and I will dote” (45-7). Alluding to mermaid and siren singing symbolizes the extent of his ardor and stiffens his seduction.

The third instance comes at the end of the same scene. AofS rendezvouses with his servant, Dromio of Syracusa (DofS), who is stuck in a similar situation: Though he's also unaware of the error, DofS has been mistaken for his identical brother, Dromio of Ephesus (DofE), by Nell, DofE's fiance. In comparing their situations, DofE and AofE both agree that the city is cursed, and so promptly plan their departure. But in doing so, he must abandon Luciana. Oh well, he thinks, “I'll stop mine ears against the mermaid's song.” (164) Where earlier in the scene AofS referred to Luciana as both a mermaid and a siren, now he only refers to her as a mermaid. This is because sirens' song is supposedly so beautiful that anybody who heard it couldn't resist it – that's why Odysseus famously incapacitated himself before approaching the sirens in The Odyssey. AofS's resolve to leave has overruled his lust, obviously Luciana does not have the sirens' power of persuasion.

Fourth and finally, in act 4.3, DofS refers to a problematic law enforcement officer as “like a base-viol in a case of leather” (23). The viol is a Renaissance- and Baroque-era ancestor to the modern violin. The bass-viol is akin to the modern cello. But Shakespeare writes base – not bass. Like the decline vs. incline pun described above, this “typo” is not an accident – it contributes to our understanding of the scene. In this context, base means inferior quality, while leather symbolizes superior quality. So describing a public safety official as such illustrates how his shady behavior has been shielded through a veneer of legitimate authority. Apparently all cops were bastards even 400 years ago!

There might or might not be additional, less obvious, musical references. Russ W. Duffin observes one potential connection in Shakespeare's Songbook, pointing out that four Shakespeare plays – including Errors – might allude to the Elizabethan song 'Loath to Depart' (p. 256).
Picture
loath_to_depart_as_a_single_voice.mp3
File Size: 461 kb
File Type: mp3
Download File

Interestingly, Duffan also notes that 'Loath to Depart' is a four-part round, which in theory could continue ad infinitum, musically capturing the hesitancy to exit articulated by the title (p. 257).
loath_to_depart_as_a_four-part_round.mp3
File Size: 1076 kb
File Type: mp3
Download File

In the opening scene of Errors, Egeon utters a phrase nearly identical to that song's title while describing his unfruitful search for his missing sons:
     Five summer have I spent in farthest Greece,
     Roaming clean through the bounds of Asia,
     And coasting homeward, came to Ephesus;
     Hopeless to find, yet loath to leave unsought
     ​Or that, or any place that harbors men. (132-6)
It's hardly conclusive, but certainly a possibility that Shakespeare intended this connection. And even if he never intended it, the parallel is still present

Though none of them have secured a spot in the standard repertoire, history contains several operas and musicals based on The Comedy of Errors. Among the better-known adaptations are Stephen Storace's 1786 opera buffa Gli Equivoci, Henry Bishop's 1819 opera The Comedy of Errors, and Richard Rodgers' and Lorenz Hart's 1938 musical The Boys From Syracuse.

It appears that the main reason Storace's opera is still remembered today has less to do with its own merits than the fact that he was a pupil of Mozart, and the libretto was written by Lorenzo Da Ponte, who collaborated with Mozart on Don Giovanni, The Marriage of Figaro, and Cosi Fan Tutte – all of which have entered the standard rep.

Bishop's opera is peculiar because its overture and 14 musical numbers draw from Shakespeare's writings (and one Marlowe poem – apparently Bishop falsely attributed it to Shakespeare), but has no apparent connection to The Comedy of Errors except for its title and character names (but not character actions):
  • Overture: References (in order) Hamlet, The Tempest, Macbeth, The Winter's Tale, Twelfth Night, Macbeth (again), The Tempest (again), Hamlet (again), Twelfth Night (again), As You Like It, The Winter's Tale (again), As You Like It (again), Macbeth (a third time), and The Winter's Tale (a third time).
  • No. 1: “It was a lover and his lass” (As You Like It: 5.3.16-33) sung by Luciana
  • No. 2: “Beauty is but a vain and doubtful good” (The Passionate Pilgrim: 13.1-12) sung by AofE
  • No. 3: “Blow, blow, thou winter wind” (As You Like It: 2.7.174-83), sung by SATB chorus
  • No. 4: “The pour soul sat singing by a sycamore tree” (Othello: 4.3.40-7), sung by Adriana
  • No. 5: “Under the greenwood tree” (As You Like It: 2.5.1-8), sung by ATTB chorus
  • No. 6: “Saint withold footed thrice” (King Lear: 3.5.120-4), sung by Cerimon (from Pericles) and AofE
  • No. 7: “Come live with me and be my love” (not written by Shakespeare – these are the opening lines of Christopher Marlowe's poem "The Passionate Shepherd to His Love"), sung by Adriana
  • No. 8: “Sweet rose, fair flower” (The Passionate Pilgrim: 10.1-6), sung by Luciana
  • No. 9: “What shall he have that killed the deer?” (As You Like It: 4.3.10-8), sung by ATTB chorus
  • No. 10: “Take, oh take those lips away” (Measure for Measure: 3.2.1-6), sung by Adriana
  • No. 11: “As it fell upon the day” (The Passionate Pilgrim: 20.1-18), sung by Adriana and Luciana
  • No. 12: “Come thou monarch of the vine” (Antony and Cleopatra: 2.7.113-8), sung by ATB chorus
  • No. 13: “Oh how this spring of love resembleth” (Two Gentlemen of Verona: 1.3.84-7), sung by Luciana
  • No. 14: “Lo! Here the gentle lark” (Venus and Adonis, 853-6), sung by Adriana
None of the 15 compositions bear any resemblance to The Comedy of Errors, which forces the question: Why did he title it so? “No one minds Bishop writing a potpurri overture and calling it Shakespeariana,” writes Christopher Wilson in Shakespeare and Music, “but why call it The Comedy of Errors?” (p. 8) Nobody seems to know...

Third, Rodgers and Hart's The Boys From Syracuse is clearly based on The Comedy of Errors. Though it takes some significant departures from Shakespeare, it also adds some interesting symbolism absent from the original. As Irene Dash writes in Shakespeare and the American Musical, Hart's lyrics to 'Falling in Love with Love' features “love's blindness intrud[ing] on the romantic notion. … [L]ove makes us unable to see a lover clearly; we must struggle for hints of his reality” (p. 29):
     I fell in love with love one night
     When the moon was full
     I was unwise with eyes
     Unable to see
     I fell in love with love
     With love everlasting
     But love fell out with me
Though Shakespeare explores the “love is blind” notion elsewhere (The Merchant of Venice: 2.6.36, A Midsummer Night's Dream: 1.1.234 & 5.1.4-22, Romeo and Juliet: 2.3.67-8, and Sonnet 148) he somewhat surprisingly does not pursue that idea in Errors, where it could nicely supplement the themes of romantic attachment and mistaken identity.

Lastly, how have composers written music to accompany performances of The Comedy of Errors? Obviously, with covid19 quarantine in place, I can't attend any live performances. But, I discovered and watched two video recordings: The first was the BBC's 1983 production, directed by James Cellan Jones, with music by Richard Holmes; the other a 1989 performance by The Stratford Festival of Canada, directed by Richard Monette, with music by Berthold Carriere.

Holmes' score employs two recurring themes. His main theme is heard only three times in its definitive form (at the very beginning, during the scene change from 4.4-5.1, and at the very end).
Picture
However it resurfaces in disguise frequently. The first variation – clearly related in rhythm and harmony, though it has a completely different cadence – is heard between 1.2-2.1, and as intermission segues to 4.1.
Picture
A second variation is heard as 3.1 transitions to 3.2.
Picture
There's also a Rennaissnace-esque secondary theme that shares similarities in its cadences to the definitive version of the main theme. It is heard three times: From 2.1-2, as 3.2 segues to intermission, and from 4.3-4.
Picture
Less creative, elaborate, and involved – but no less effective – than Holmes, Carriere's score is based on arrangements of J.S. Bach. While several of Bach's most famous melodies are heard throughout, a swung up-tempo rendition of the tune from his Cantata 140 “Wachet Auf” serves as the play's principal theme.
Picture
Were I to compose music for Errors, I'd write a memorable main theme in two distinct tonalities – perhaps E major after Ephesus and E-flat major after Syracuse (S being German for E-flat) – to capture the whimsical nature of the story and its theme of mistaken identity. But I wouldn't try to do to much – the music would be limited to scene changes, and there'd be little underscoring. The danger of doing anything more sophisticated is that the play is already confusing enough – there's no reason to complicate further! I'd write snippets based on that main theme for each of the following:
  • Beginning: Main theme in primary tonality
  • Melancholy underscoring during Egeon's history in 1.1
  • Scene change between 1.1-2 requires more somber incidental music (to reflect Egeon's death sentence)
  • 1.2-2.1 scene change music
  • 2.1-2 scene change music
  • 2.2-3.1 scene change music
  • Comedic underscoring in 3.1, as AofE is locked out of his own house
  • 3.1-2 scene change music
  • Romantic underscoring as AofS attempts to seduce Luciana in 3.2
  • 3.2 ending, leading to intermission: main theme in secondary tonality
  • 4.1 opening after intermission: main theme in secondary tonality
  • 4.1-2 scene change music
  • 4.2-3 scene change music
  • 4.3-4 scene change music
  • Comedic underscoring in 4.4 amid the arrests and accusations
  • 4.4-5.1 scene change music
  • 5.1: Comedic underscoring during chase to abbey; religious music as Aemelia emerges; royal music for the Duke's entry; conciliatory underscoring as everybody realizes their misunderstandings
  • Ending & bows: main theme in primary tonality
0 Comments

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Shakespeare Blog

    A workshop for developing thoughts on William Shakespeare's writings.

    Archives

    July 2020
    June 2020

    Categories

    All
    All's Well That Ends Well
    A Midsummer Night's Dream
    Anthony And Cleopatra
    As You Like It
    Coriolanus
    Cymbeline
    Hamlet
    Henry IV
    Henry V
    Henry VI
    Henry VIII
    Julius Caesar
    King John
    King Lear
    Love's Labor's Lost
    Macbeth
    Measure For Measure
    Much Ado About Nothing
    Music
    Othello
    Pericles
    Richard II
    Richard III
    Romeo And Juliet
    Scene Charts
    Soundtrack
    Summaries
    Taming Of The Shrew
    Tennis
    The Comedy Of Errors
    The Merchant Of Venice
    The Merry Wives Of Windsor
    The Tempest
    The Winter's Tale
    Timon Of Athens
    Titus Andronicus
    Troilus And Cressida
    Twelfth Night
    Two Gentlemen Of Verona
    Two Noble Kinsmen

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
  • Beatles Minute
  • Pop Goes the Theory
  • Calendar
    • Upcoming Events
    • Past Events
    • Newsletter Sign-Up
  • Blogs
    • Beatles Blog
    • Pop Music Blog
    • Star Wars Blog
    • Origami Blog
    • Shakespeare Blog
  • Contact