FLIP SIDE BEATLES: presentations, books, musical analysis
  • Beatles Minute
  • Pop Goes the Theory
  • Calendar
    • Upcoming Events
    • Past Events
    • Newsletter Sign-Up
  • Blogs
    • Beatles Blog
    • Pop Music Blog
    • Star Wars Blog
    • Origami Blog
    • Shakespeare Blog
  • Contact

Inspiration or Plagiarism?: 'You Need Love' vs 'Whole Lotta Love'

3/14/2018

0 Comments

 
Willie Dixon, probably the foremost blues composer of the mid-20th Century, penned a song titled 'You Need Love', which he gave to Muddy Waters to record in 1962. Seven years later, that song's lyrics would be the inspiration for Led Zeppelin's 'Whole Lotta Love'.
Muddy Waters: 'You Need Love' (1962), Third Verse (1:57-end)
I ain't foolin', you need schoolin'
Baby, you know you need coolin'
Woman, way down inside
Woman, you need love
You got to have some love
Mmmm
She got to have some love
Mmmm
She got to have some love
Led Zeppelin: 'Whole Lotta Love' (1969), First Verse (0:11-0:45)
You need coolin', baby, I'm not foolin'
I'm gonna send you back to schoolin'
Way down inside, honey you need it
I'm gonna give you my love
I'm gonna give you my love
Oh!
Wanna whole lotta love
Wanna whole lotta love
Wanna whole lotta love
Wanna whole lotta love
Dixon sued Zeppelin for plagiarism in the 1980s, settling out of court for an undisclosed amount.

While the lyrical similarities are undeniable, there remains some confusion whether or not the music (independent of the words) is original or not.

Jimmy Page claimed the former: "If you took the lyric out and listened to the track instrumentally, it is clearly something new and different - a completely original piece of music" (English, page 198).

But Zeppelin biographer Mick Wall claimed the latter: "Even the most memorable part of the song, that punchy B-D-B-D-E riff, was derived from the original guitar refrain of the Muddy Waters original" (Wall, page 149).

Unfortunately, Wall provides no evidence to support his claim. Nor does he appear to understand what a refrain is. (It's a lyrical device - not a musical one - so I'm not sure how a "guitar refrain" is even possible since a guitar can't sing lyrics.) While Waters does use a refrain (corresponding to the title lyrics) three times in the song (0:19-0:40, 1:19-1:31, and 2:07-2:16 - each one slightly different in content and duration), the accompanying guitar (which more or less double the vocals) is not strongly related to the Zeppelin riff. The best example (the closest to 'Whole Lotta Love') is heard in the second of those three refrains.
Picture
The circled measure does share modest similarities to 'Whole Lotta Love' in both pitch (B-D-E) and its syncopated rhythm...
Picture
... but it's only a superficial resemblance. If this is what Wall has in mind, it's a pretty weak case. It's only heard twice (once in the first refrain, once in the second), and it's not very prominent (you have to really look for it to find it).

​Another clue comes from author Tim English, in his book Sounds Like Teen Spirit: "The guitar lick on 'Whole Lotta Love['] is not dissimilar from what is played on Waters' 'You Need Love'" (English, page 197).

English makes no mention of the refrain, so I assume he's referring to the opening guitar licks. I've transcribed the first several measures below.
Picture
Yes, the fourth full measure also bears a passing resemblance to 'Whole Lotta Love' in pitch and rhythms, but I find that, too, to be more incidental than significant.

I have to agree with Page (and against Walls and English) on this one: 'Whole Lotta Love' is musically independent from 'You Need Love'. There are superficial musical similarities and a strong similarity in character (they're both blues songs), but nowhere near the resemblance of the lyrics.

Lastly, Robert Plant's vocals are worth mentioning. Just as he borrowed the lyrics from Muddy Waters, so too he borrows the vocal style of Steve Marriott, lead singer of The Small Faces, who released their own version of the song, 'You Need Loving', in 1966.
Plant greatly admired Marriott's vocal style, calling him a "master of contemporary white blues" (Shadwick, page 262), and deliberately imitated it. And nowhere is that influence more apparent than on 'Whole Lotta Love'.


SOURCES

English, Tim. 2016. Sounds Like Teen Spirit: Stolen Melodies, Ripped-Off Riffs, and the Secret History of Rock and Roll. [No publisher or city given].

Shadwick, Keith. 2005. Led Zeppelin 1968-1980. Backbeat Books; San Francisco, CA.

Wall, Mick. 2008. When Giants Walked the Earth: A Biography of Led Zeppelin. St. Martin's Griffin; New York, NY.
0 Comments

    Aaron Krerowicz, pop music scholar

    An informal but highly analytic study of popular music.

    Archives

    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018

    Categories

    All
    AABA Form
    Alanis Morissette
    Ariana Grande
    Asymmetric Rhymes
    Augmented Sixths
    Bass Line
    Beatles
    Beck's Bolero
    Billy Joel
    Black Dog
    Bluegrass
    Bolero
    Bon Jovi
    Brian Hebert
    Bring It On Home
    Cheap Trick
    Chordal Accretion
    Christopher Doll
    Country
    Dazed And Confused
    Functional Harmony
    George Harrison
    Good Times Bad Times
    Half-diminished Sevenths
    Harmony
    Have A Cigar
    Here Comes The Sun
    Hexatonic Pole
    Houses Of The Holy (song)
    Howlin Wolf
    How Many More Times
    How Many More Years
    Interview
    James Jamerson
    Jeff Beck
    Jimmie Rodgers
    Jimmy Nash
    Jimmy Ruffin
    Kiss
    Led Zeppelin (album)
    Led Zeppelin (band)
    Led Zeppelin II (album)
    Led Zeppelin III (album)
    Led Zeppelin IV (album)
    Linkin Park
    Los Lonely Boys
    Lou Reed
    Luke Bryan
    Madonna
    Mandocello
    Metallica
    Meteora
    Meter
    Milli Vanilli
    Mode Mixture
    Modulation
    Muddy Waters
    Multifunctional Harmony
    Muse
    Neapolitan Chord
    Nitty Gritty Dirt Band
    Organic Development
    Out On The Tiles
    Physical Graffiti
    Picardy Third
    Pink Floyd
    Pivot Chord
    Plagiarism
    Rhythmic Displacement
    Rock N Roll Animal
    Secondary Diminished
    Shapes Of Things
    Smokestack Lightning
    Something
    Sour Girl
    Stairway To Heaven
    Steve Marriott
    Stone Temple Pilots
    Structure
    Sweet Jane
    The Hunter
    The Small Faces
    The T-Bones
    Tom Waits
    Tragedy
    Welcome To The Machine
    What Becoems Of The Brokenhearted
    When The Levee Breaks
    Whole Lotta Love
    Willie Dixon
    Wish You Were Here

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
  • Beatles Minute
  • Pop Goes the Theory
  • Calendar
    • Upcoming Events
    • Past Events
    • Newsletter Sign-Up
  • Blogs
    • Beatles Blog
    • Pop Music Blog
    • Star Wars Blog
    • Origami Blog
    • Shakespeare Blog
  • Contact